If a simple, proven and cost-effective option could help gifted children receive the academic services they need, wouldn't most schools rush to offer it?
Academic acceleration: A proven alternative
We know that the trend toward differentiated instruction and the elimination of ability grouping has deprived gifted students of a challenging learning environment in many classrooms. Yet one simple and cost-effective option is academic acceleration. Full-grade, or even single subject acceleration, not only enhances gifted students' education, but alleviates some of the burden teachers face trying to differentiate instruction. Early entrance into kindergarten, dual-enrollment in college classes, and online programming are other forms of acceleration. And most research (see references below) has documented the benefits of acceleration, and refuted the widely held belief that it is socially or emotionally harmful. Gifted children who accelerate thrive both academically and socially.
Yet when parents or a brave teacher suggest acceleration, they are often met with resistance. We can't do that. It wouldn't be fair to the other kids. Your child might not fit in. He/she would miss out on important curriculum. And so on...
There is something threatening about academic acceleration.
When a child with a learning disability or another challenge is evaluated, most schools go to great lengths to find accommodations. Why is there such resistance to addressing the needs of a gifted child? Here are some possible reasons:
1. There will be chaos!
Far removed from the one-room schoolhouse, there are strict rules today for assignment to specific grades and classes. Age cut-off dates for kindergarten vary from state to state, and sometimes town to town, and children are expected to fulfill specific curricular requirements based on their year in school. Once parents or teachers "break" these rules, fear of chaos ensues.
2. Curriculum reigns supreme
School policy often requires that teachers adhere to the curriculum. Each chapter and section must be covered - learning be damned! If a child accelerates, he misses out on some of that material. Yet, we know that much of what is taught, especially in elementary school, is not necessarily crucial information that won't be assimilated at a later time. When gifted children bypass some of the curriculum rather than languishing in classrooms unsuited to their learning needs, they may be more likely to maintain their intrinsic interest in learning. As Peter DeWitt recently noted:
"When we are too concerned about covering curriculum, instead of seeing students as individuals with strengths and weaknesses, we are more at risk of putting them in a box instead of thinking outside of it. And one group of our students that need our best thinking are students who may no longer need to be in our classrooms at all, and those are the students who need to be accelerated."
3. It is elitist
If a child is permitted to enter kindergarten early or accelerate to another grade, school administrators often fear a backlash of criticism from district parents claiming elitism. Acceleration is viewed by some as a special privilege or a badge of honor, resulting in anger and defensiveness. School officials are left to explain that acceleration is critical and necessary for a particular child's educational needs; it is not a reward for good behavior or excellent grades. This can be tiresome. Administrators need to pick their battles...and this may not be a cause they wish to champion.
4. Who are these gifted you speak of?
Some school districts or teachers lack training or even basic knowledge about gifted children. They may not fully grasp the extent to which these students learn with more depth and intensity, and grasp material at a much quicker pace. They may equate ability with grades and achievement and refuse to consider the underachieving gifted or gifted students who act out due to boredom. They may hold stereotypical images of what a gifted child looks like, and overlook children who don't fit the mold. They may assume that gifted children's needs can be met reasonably well in a regular classroom and that differentiated instruction is sufficient. Some may even believe that gifted students' needs can be sacrificed for the overall good, and that resources should be tailored to struggling or average students.
5. What makes them so special?
Teachers are people just like everyone else. Despite their training, they carry their personal beliefs, emotional impressions from childhood, and unconscious prejudices along with them. Some may have had negative experiences with gifted children in the past. Some may not understand giftedness and may hold negative stereotypes about gifted children or their families. Some may have endured uncomfortable interactions with parents who have pressured them to provide special accommodations. These resentments may color their professional judgment when decisions regarding acceleration are needed, and result in withholding what is perceived as special treatment.
How academic acceleration can help gifted children
Academic acceleration is not the right answer for every gifted child; but it always should be an available option. With research showing that up to 45% of students in upper elementary grades perform at least one year above their grade level, it appears that many students - not just the gifted - are receiving an education lacking sufficient challenge. A 45-year follow-up study of gifted children found that those who skipped a grade were 60% more likely to earn a Ph.D. or have a patent than those who did not accelerate, and twice as likely to have a Ph.D. in a STEM field. And recent meta-analytic findings from studies of academic acceleration confirmed its benefits - both academically and socially. Researchers Steenburgen-Hu and Moon concluded that:
"...accelerated students tend to outperform students who are not accelerated in their performance on standardized achievement tests, college grades, degrees obtained, status of universities or colleges attended, and career status. Accelerants equal or surpass non-accelerants in self-concept, self-esteem, self-confidence, social relationships, participation in extracurricular activities, and life satisfaction."
It is time to put the false assumptions and misconceptions to rest. Acceleration can enhance learning, and has a positive impact on long-term achievement and social and emotional well-being. If your school district is unaware of the benefits of acceleration, you might consider sharing information from NAGC, SENG, tip.Duke or from the articles listed below. Any child who might benefit from academic acceleration deserves this powerful and well-researched opportunity.
Assouline, S., Colangelo, N. & VanTassel-Baska, J. (2015) A nation empowered: Evidence trumps the excuses holding back America's brightest students (Vol.1). Iowa City: University of Iowa, Connie Belin & Jacqueline N. Blank International Center for Gifted Education and Talent Development.
Colangelo, N., Assouline, S., Marron, M., Castellano, J., Clinkenbeard, P., Rogers, C., Calvert, E., Malek, R. & Smith, D. (2010). Guidelines for developing an academic acceleration policy. National work group on acceleration. Journal of Advanced Academics, 21, 180-203.
Lee, S., Olszewski-Kubilius, P. & Thomson, D. (2012). Academically gifted students perceived interpersonal competence and peer relationships. Gifted Child Quarterly, 56, 90-104.
Lee, S., Olszerski, Kubilius, P., & Paternel, G. (2014). The efficacy of academic acceleration for gifted minority students. Gifted Child Quarterly, 54, 189-208.
Lubinski, D., Webb, R., Morelock, M., & Benbow, C. (2001). Top 1 in 10,000: A 10-Year follow-up of profoundly gifted. Journal of Applied Psychology, 86, 720.
Missett, T., Brunner, M, Callahan, C., Moon, T., & Azana, A. (2014). Exploring teacher beliefs and use of acceleration, ability grouping, and formative assessment. Journal of the Education of the Gifted., 37, 245-268.
Park, G., Lubinski, D., & Benbow, C. (2013). When less is more: Effects of grade skipping on adult STEM productivity among mathematically precocious adolescents. Journal of Educational Psychology, 105, 176-198.
Steenbergen-Hu, S. & Moon, S. (2011). The effects of acceleration on high-ability learners: A meta-analysis. Gifted Child Quarterly, 55, 39-53.
This blog is part of Hoagie's Gifted Education Page Blog Hop on Acceleration. To see more blogs, click on the following link: http://www.hoagiesgifted.org/blog_hop_acceleration_2.htm
Great post! On our own journey through acceleration, we endured a lot of what you are talking about here. Luckily, our progressive administration managed to overcome district's resistance, and our daughter was the first in years to skip a grade. As I wrote in my own post, she is thriving now while she was barely tolerating school before. But... we are battling this yet again, this time on single subject acceleration.ReplyDelete
Natalie, So glad you were able to implement the changes you needed for your daughter. I hope you can get her the additional help she needs. Thanks so much for your comments.Delete
Spot on! It's maddening. We have all this research and no action.ReplyDelete
Thanks, Cait. I appreciate your feedbackDelete
This is one of the most frustrating things I encountered as a gifted coordinator. We even had a student math-accelerated and my administrator stopped it. What?!Delete
Judy, That is so frustrating. I hope that your administration eventually wakes up to what will work for these students.Delete
You make such a strong, reasoned case for acceleration, Gail!ReplyDelete
Paula, Thanks for your feedback!Delete
Your description of a gifted child that isn't being challenged is spot on! It's disheartening that their is still such resistance to acceleration, when it is such an easy fix for many students. You do a great job of addressing each of the barriers to it!ReplyDelete
Jen, Thanks so much. It is striking, isn't it, that a cost-effective and simple approach would invoke such resistance? Thanks again.Delete
I'm so happy to see more and more people advocating for acceleration. My son was accelerated (skipped one grade) two years ago. It took a year-long struggle with administration and teacher but thanks to the tireless support and advocacy of several other school staff (the GT pull-out program teacher, the Instructional Partner, and the amazing school counselor!) we got permission for the skip. And it was like a fog lifted! My boy was happy, fit right in socially, didn't miss a beat academically. It's been a fantastic two years since then and we've no regrets. For those gifted children for whom acceleration is a good fit, it should be a much easier process! Thanks for writing about it on your blog, the more we shine the light on acceleration as an option the more administrators and schools will (hopefully) be willing to give it serious consideration.ReplyDelete
Heather, Thank you for letting us know the success you found through advocating for your son. It is unfortunate that it was so difficult, but it is wonderful that it is working out so well for him. Hopefully, more school districts will become open to this option and parents like you will not have to struggle so hard to make this happen for their children.Delete
Yes! I think you concisely stated the common arguments that I heard with my son and so many others face. Hoping that it will open discussions about the benefits of acceleration.ReplyDelete
Jen, Thanks so much for your comments!Delete
Great post Gail! Well articulated and researched!ReplyDelete
Thank you for a wonderful post! I hope parents and educators continue to share it widely.ReplyDelete